Commenting and Analyzing Article critique Order Instructions: The writer will have to read each of this post and react to them by commenting, analyzing and supporting with relevant articles. The writer will have to read carefully before giving constructive comments on the post.
The writer should write one paragraph of at least 150 words. APA and in-text citation must be used as each respond to the two posts must have in-text citations. The writer will have to use an article to supports his comments in each of the articles. Address the content of each post below in one paragraph each, analysis and evaluation of the topic, as well as the integration of relevant resources.
It is Critical that the writer uses two pear review articles at the minimum of not more than 5 years old to support the facts
I will send the articles via email
Commenting and Analyzing Article critique Sample Answer
Article 1 Critique
Investment by stakeholders in organizations is usually attributed to several reasons and is often beyond after-tax profits. Stockholder’s equity and after-tax profits are two factors that are likely to be put under consideration by stakeholders prior a stakeholder invests in an organization. Hence, it is essential to consider non-durable and durable goods and services philosophy of an organization corporate social responsibility (CSR). According to Forchuk & Roberts (2014) critiquing of research, the article requires an evaluation of all aspects of the paper including the research questions, methods, and findings. For instance, the research question evaluates how stockholder’s and after-tax profits for non-durable goods and durable goods in manufacturing corporations in the United States. The researcher used t tests, ANOVA and linear regression to analyze data collected from manufacturing corporations in this quantitative study (Forchuk & Roberts, 2014). The means for after-tax profit and stockholders’ equity for non-durable goods were found to be higher than that of durable goods. Inferential statistics show the non-significant relationship between after-tax profits and stockholders’ equity for durable and nondurable from the collected data meaning additional analysis is needed to make succinct conclusions (Forchuk & Roberts, 2014).
Article 2 Critique
This qualitative case study aimed to examine the factors of leadership style and education that influences business development subsequently leading to their success or possible failure based on the bivariate analysis. According to Lee (2013) bivariate analysis involves the analysis of two variables to determine the empirical relationship that exists between them. The research questions seek to evaluate the factors described by small business owners as necessary in the creation of successful start-ups as well as how managerial experience and leadership style influences the success or failure of start-up businesses. The sample size of 90 businesses selected at the Upstate of South Carolina was considerably good to provide reliable data (Lee, 2013). The collected data show that the manager’s experience and business existence were relatively similar. The correlation analysis indicates that there is a statistically significant strong positive relationship between the success of small business and managerial experience and leadership style. According to Lee (2013), appropriate statistical analysis provides elaborate findings and conclusions to identify gaps for future research.
Commenting and Analyzing Article critique References
Forchuk, C. & Roberts, J. (2014). How to critique qualitative research articles. Canadian Journal of Nursing Research, 25(4), 47–56.
Lee, P. (2013). Understanding and critiquing qualitative research papers. Nursing Times, 102(29), 30–32.
